Cocktail Cupcakes, My Base Recipe

I have been meaning to post this for about 2 years. Seriously. I developed the idea for these cupcakes late 2009/early 2010, then there was a time when I was getting them right, tweaking this and that. When I did get them right, there wasn't time to take photos for a post, they were heading straight out the door for an 18 year old's birthday. 

Not just any Strawberry Daiquiri cupcakes! My first ever batch of Real Cocktail Cupcakes

Not just any Strawberry Daiquiri cupcakes! My first ever batch of Real Cocktail Cupcakes

Eventually I did take the time to get photos for a post, and there the photos sat, just waiting patiently while my life and other posts butted in ahead of their internet glory. 

But, we're just about at another bringing in of a New Year and I just couldn't let them sit on my harddrive untouched for another year. Besides, these would be great at a New Year's party!

They'd also be great at, as aforementioned, an 18 year old's party (or 21 depending where you are in the world), a hen's night or just any occasion where you think they'd be appropriate.

Cocktail cupcakes. 

Electric Lemonade cupcakes for an 18th's birthday. Yes, I realise they're very very blue, please don't judge the amount of colouring I used :P

Electric Lemonade cupcakes for an 18th's birthday. Yes, I realise they're very very blue, please don't judge the amount of colouring I used :P

I know, they've been done before. Cocktail themed cupcakes where there may or may not be a spike of booze in the frosting. Colours and trimmings matching that of the cocktail in its liquid form. 

Mine are different. In fact, I dare say that mine are possibly the first. (In the internet searching I've done nothing like this has come up in any of my search results, but you never know, maybe someone just hasn't blogged them yet).

Hidden beneath the seemingly innocent frosting flavoured with fruits and booze of your favourite cocktail, as would be in any other cocktail themed cupcake, and nestled snuggly in the sponge, is a jelly (jello) shot

A proper boozey jelly shot. 

The kind you make for parties that require jelly shots. Mostly alcohol flavoured with a bit of whatever flavour you think it needs to pass for a fun jelly shot, all held together with gelatine.

A delicious pineapple, vodka and Cointreau jelly shot hidden in a Flirtini cupcake

A delicious pineapple, vodka and Cointreau jelly shot hidden in a Flirtini cupcake

Well, I say that, but here's where some of my time was spent, in perfecting that jelly shot. 

It all started when I was out with my hubby, we were enjoying lunch and I was on a new bloggers high. I was new to the food blogging world and, as I'm sure others have experienced, what seemed like millions of ideas were flowing forth, just waiting to be digitally input into what was my Wordpress part of the online world. 

My candied lime slices need some work but these Cosmopolitan cupcakes were otherwise very tasty!

My candied lime slices need some work but these Cosmopolitan cupcakes were otherwise very tasty!

I'd come across cocktail themed cupcakes and decided that I could make them better. I could make any recipe better at that stage! (I've come to learn that I'm not the only foodie out there and that many a recipe is better than mine). 

Actually, truth be told, this was my husband's idea, (and he likes to boast a little about this from time to time) why don't I put a jelly shot into the cupcakes? 

*lightbulb* *much excitement* *lots of rambling about how much fun that could be*

Um. Gelatine melts at room temperature, most cupcakes are horrible when kept cold in the fridge, you'd end up with a soggy mess of a cupcake. 

Thankfully, just about a week before, I'd come across agar agar. 

*lighting hit again* *much more excitement* *even more babbling on*

Cooking the agar mixture

Cooking the agar mixture

For those of you not familiar with agar agar, it's a vegetarian friendly gelatine made from a kind of seaweed, and in fact, it sets between 31°C & 40°C and will stay quite happily at room temperature without melting.

Not only did I discover a fun twist on the cocktail themed cupcake, but vegetarian's could also partake and be merry! I also discovered that another name for agar agar is gulaman. Gulaman. Gulaman! That word's there on my list of novelty things to say like Labradoodle. Gulaman. I don't know why but it makes me smile.

My first attempt at cocktail cupcakes. I punched out cylinders of set agar and put them into the holes of the cupcakes. I've since found a better way of filling the cupcakes

My first attempt at cocktail cupcakes. I punched out cylinders of set agar and put them into the holes of the cupcakes. I've since found a better way of filling the cupcakes

In my quest for spiking each cupcake with a boozey jelly shot I started out quite simply setting the agar in a dish, punching out circles of it with the same apple corer I used to punch out the middles of the cupcakes, and then simply inserting the jelly cyclinder into each one.

It worked just fine, but I was sure it could be better. I didn't like that the jelly shot could fall out of the cupcake once you got to it.

And then, ephiphany, agar sets really quickly in the fridge, even quicker than when it gets to room temperature, which was one of the things I had to get used to, keeping the mixture warm enough so that it stayed a pourable liquid but not so hot that all that lovely alcohol evaporated. More on that later.

Cosmopolitan jelly shots poured into chilled cupcakes

Cosmopolitan jelly shots poured into chilled cupcakes

Pretty simply I figured the best way to get the jelly shot into the cupcake was to remove however much of the middle of the cupcake I wanted to fill. Pop the cupcakes in the fridge for 20-30 minutes so that the middles were nicely chilled, then letting the agar cool as much as I could allow it before it would begin to set, and once all the stars aligned and choruses could be heard (just kidding, it's not that tricky), pouring the agar into each cupcake. Once it hits the chilled sponge it sets immediately, forming a perfect barrier so that the agar didn't leech into the sponge but had time to set in the middle where it wasn't quite as cool.


Electric Lemonade-1859.jpg

Right, about the alcohol evaporating thing. We all know that alcohol evaporates quickly when heated, and because agar needs to be kept above 40°C to stay liquid, you're probably wondering how I kept the alcohol in the jelly shot. Turns out it either takes a lot of heat or a lot of time to remove the alcohol from the liquid it's in. So when you're cooking a stew with a lovely red wine, because the nature of a stew is that it cooks for a good long time, the alcohol in the wine is pretty much gone by the time you eat it. Same as when you flambé something, the extreme amount of heat on a small amount of liquid evaporates the alcohol.

Just to be on the safe side (the whole point of a jelly shot is the alcohol) I've come up with a way that I think keeps as much of the alcohol in the jelly shot as possible. I'm not a food scientist so I could be wrong, but from tasting my potent little agar shots, I'd say that I'm doing the right thing.

What I do is I heat the agar with water/fruit juice/fruit purée and let it melt and cook with none of the alcohol yet added. Once the agar has melted and it's ready for the alcohol, I then heat the alcohol up to about 50°C and mix it into the agar mixture. You have to heat the alcohol otherwise if you add cold alcohol to the agar mixture it will cool too much and begin to set, and I heat it up at the end so that the hot alcohol isn't sitting around waiting for the agar mixture to be ready with its alcohol content evaporating.

Flirtini cupcakes

Flirtini cupcakes

As you may have guessed from reading all of this, these cupcakes are a little fussy to make and do require a bit of skill or at least baking common sense, so if you've never made a cupcake in your life, you probably don't want to start with these. 


Below is the basic jelly shot recipe as well as a base recipe for vanilla cupcakes and Swiss buttercream that you can then take and put your own flavours to to make your own cocktail cupcakes, like my Flirtini cupcakes.

Bottom's up!



Basic Vanilla Cupcake

You can use any cupcake recipe you like, but I'm giving you my favourite recipe as a base, it's the vanilla cupcake from Magnolia's bakery. You can stir in zests, extracts or fruit chunks to mirror your cocktail cupcake

Makes 24 cupcakes, easily halved to make 12


1 1/2 cups Self Raising Flour

1 1/4 cups All Purpose Flour

225g Unsalted Butter, softened (1 cup / 2 sticks)

2 cups Granulated Sugar

4 Large Eggs, at room temperature

1 cup Milk

1 tsp Vanilla Extract

1/4 tsp Salt



  • Preheat oven to 180°C (160°C Fan Assisted / 350°F)
  • Line 2 muffin tins with cupcake liners
  • In a small bowl sift the flours together then set aside
  • Combine the milk and vanilla extract in a jug or small bowl and set aside
  • In a large bowl cream the butter until smooth
  • Add the sugar and beat until fluffy, about 3 minutes
  • Add eggs 1 at a time, beating thoroughly after each addition. Scrape the sides of the bowl between adding each egg
  • Add 1/3 of the dry ingredients to the butter and beat until just incorporated
  • Beat in 1/2 of the milk & vanilla
  • Repeat the previous 2 steps, ending with the last of the flour. Scrape down the sides of the bowl between each addition
  • Spoon the batter into the prepared cupcake liners to about 3/4 full
  • Bake for 20 - 25 mins or until a toothpick comes out clean
  • Leave to cool in the pans for 15 mins
  • Remove cupcakes from the pans and cool completely on a wire rack before filling & frosting




Basic Swiss Meringue Buttercream

My favourite frosting is Swiss Buttercream, I find it's not overly sweet like basic buttercream which is just what I prefer, but of course you can use any frosting you prefer. Add zests, liqueurs, alcohol or extracts to mirror your cocktail of choice.

This makes enough for a generous swirl on 24 cupcakes. Easily halved.


6 Large Egg Whites, room temperature

300g Granulated White Sugar

525g Unsalted Butter, room temperature

Seeds scraped from 2 vanilla beans


3-4 tsp Vanilla Extract (to taste)


Zests, Liqueurs or Extracts (to taste)

Gel or Paste Colour (optional)



  • Combine the egg whites and sugar in a heatproof bowl
  • Put the bowl over a pot of simmering water
  • Whisk over heat until all the sugar is dissolved and it resembles marshmallow fluff, about 3 mins
  • Pour the mixture into a large bowl and beat until the mixture is cool and you have a glossy meringue
  • Beat in the butter a tablespoon at a time, making sure it's completely mixed in before adding more
  • Tip: At some point it will look curdled, DON'T WORRY! Once you've added all of the butter, just keep beating and it will come together to form a smooth, creamy buttercream
  • Beat in flavourings and gel colours of your choice




Basic Agar Jelly/Jello Shot Filling

You can get agar in different forms. 1Tbsp flaked agar = 1tsp powdered agar. 1Tbsp flaked / 1 tsp powdered sets 1 cup / 250ml of liquid. I've used a bit more for ease of math and a firmer set.


2 Tbsp Agar Agar Flakes


2 tsp Agar Agar Powder

150ml - 200ml Alcohol (depending on how strong you want it)

200ml - 250ml Fruit Juice (to make up 400ml liquid in total including alcohol)


400ml Ready Made Cocktail Mix (like Smirnoff's Cosmopolitan)

Sugar to taste



  • Combine agar and fruit juice in a saucepan and allow to stand for about 10mins
  • Add sugar, if using, and bring mixture to the boil, stirring constantly
  • Simmer for 5 mins or until sugar and agar has dissolved, stirring
  • Tip: Agar melts at 85°C
  • Remove from heat
  • When agar mixture cools to +- 60°C, heat alcohol in a seperate saucepan until it reaches 50°C
  • Remove alcohol from heat and add to agar mixture, stirring to thoroughly combine
  • If mixture is now over 50°C, leave to cool till it reaches about 50°C
  • Tip: Agar solidifies between 31°C - 40°C so you don't want it to drop too low
  • Pour into prepared cupcakes as seen below



Cupcake Assembly

  • Using a round pastry cutter or apple corer, remove the centres of each cupcake so you're left with a well to fill
  • Put cupcakes in the fridge to chill for 20-30mins
  • Prepare agar mixture as above
  • Leave to cool just to the point where it's still liquid but not yet setting
  • Tip: It's easiest to have the agar mixture in a saucepan with a pouring spout or in a jug
  • Remove cupcakes from the fridge (make sure the centres are chilled)
  • Pour the agar mixture into the centre of each cupcake
  • Tip: The agar should set really quickly, but you can speed up the process by putting the filled cupcakes back in the fridge for 5-10mins
  • Once agar is set, frost and decorate as desired

Vanilla cupcake recipe adapted from More from Magnolia by Magnolia's Bakery

Posted on December 19, 2011 and filed under Baked, Sweet.